A Christmas Story Christmas

A Christmas Story Christmas is the best sequel of A Christmas Story bestest movie ever !!!

Peter McGinn

2022-12-02

70%

I haven’t watched any other sequels of the original movie, so I have no basis for comparison there. I have read that this one is significantly better than other sequels. I thought it was okay. Of course it leaned heavily on the original movie, as you’d expect, with plenty of references to events from that story and even short video clips. (Don’t miss the sign in the bar that is a tribute to Jean Shepherd’s book that this franchise is based on.) Leaning on the original is fine, and quite apt as the story doubles as a tribute to the late Old Man. The writing is competent, though lacking the sparkle and delight of the Jean Shepherd original. But it wasn’t as predictable either as I feared it would be with subplots such as the missing presents and Ralph’s fledgling writing career. In fact, I was pleasantly surprised at what they did with those subplots, avoiding cliched pitfalls in favor of more sensible resolutions. So I found it was worth my time watching it, though it won’t make the short list of holiday films I watch every year, such as with the original Christmas Story. Actually, I wonder if it might have gained a bit more magic if it had more closely followed Ralph’s kids rather than the adults as it did. That would have been a tough script to write though, with people relentlessly comparing it to the original. I write novels in my spare time: perhaps I will attempt a bit of fan fiction writing and try it, just for kicks. Hmm.

TheFilmCritics.org

2026-08-18

50%

Nostalgia can be a powerful thing, but it can also be a trap, and A Christmas Story Christmas spends much of its time caught somewhere between the two. This long-delayed legacy sequel returns to a familiar world with just enough warmth and affection to justify the reunion, even if it struggles to recapture the effortless charm of its predecessor. Peter Billingsley slips comfortably back into the role of Ralphie, and the return of several familiar faces gives the film its strongest moments. There is genuine pleasure in seeing these characters together again, particularly when the story allows them to simply interact rather than wink at the audience. The film also finds a more mature emotional center in its story of family, grief, and the pressure of keeping Christmas traditions alive. Those quieter moments give the sequel some heart, and the attempt to move Ralphie beyond childhood is more interesting than simply repeating the old formula. Unfortunately, repetition is exactly where the movie often lands. Several scenes feel engineered to echo memorable moments from the original, and the callbacks can become distracting rather than endearing. The humor is similarly inconsistent, with a few amusing bits surrounded by jokes that feel forced or overly familiar. The episodic structure also keeps the story from building much momentum. Instead of flowing naturally toward a strong payoff, the film sometimes feels like a collection of holiday sketches connected by nostalgia and Christmas decorations. A Christmas Story Christmas is a pleasant enough return to an old neighborhood. It has warmth, a likable cast, and a few genuinely touching moments, but it never quite escapes the shadow of the film that made audiences want to revisit it in the first place.